California Integrated Waste Management Board

 

Organics Home

Compost & Mulch

Biosolids

Sustainable Landscaping

Home Gardening

Food Scrap Management

Conversion Technologies

Events

Publications

Organics Site Index

External Links

Purchasing Compost and Mulch

Compost Quality: Performance Requirement Characteristics

Choose the performance need(s) you are interested in to see a list of characteristics you should look for in terms of feedstock type, salinity, composting method, stability/maturity, nutrients and pH.

Source of Available Nutrients

  • Feedstock Type (Compost Ingredients)
    The nutrients in the feedstock will determine the available nutrients in the final product. Compost made from manures and biosolids is frequently higher in nitrogen (N) than that made primarily from yard trimmings or wood.
  • Salinity
    Not a significant factor
  • Effect of Composting Method
    The anaerobic compost process (exposed to little or no oxygen) generates significant amounts of ammonia (NH3) that are released into the atmosphere, leaving less nitrogen in the compost product.  Compost that is produced through an aerobic process (exposed to adequate amounts of oxygen) generates less volatile ammonia.
  • Stability/Maturity
    Stable and mature compost contains a variety of available macronutrients, such as carbon (C), nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P) and potassium (K).  Compost also contains micronutrients, such as copper (Cu), iron (Fe) and zinc (Zn).  Unstable compost can immobilize nitrogen and make it unavailable for plant use.  See section on assessing stability/maturity.
  • Nutrients
    Most compost suppliers will give an analysis of major nutrient content in compost.  However, not all of the nutrients are available for plant use.
  • pH
    The pH of the growing medium plays a large role in the availability of plant nutrients.   In general, the pH of the compost should be greater than 5.  However, pH of the soil should be taken into account.

Source of beneficial microorganisms

  • Feedstock Type (Compost Ingredients)
    Some research suggests that carbon-rich feedstocks produce a compost with a higher fungal content and that nitrogen-rich feedstocks produce a compost with a higher bacterial content.  More diverse feedstock may result in a more diverse population of microorganisms.  Carbon-rich feedstocks include leaves and yard trimmings.   Nitrogen-rich feedstocks include manures.
  • Salinity
    Not a significant factor
  • Effect of Composting Method
    Aerobically composted material is more likely to contain beneficial microorganisms than anaerobically digested or processed materials.  Large compost piles may be more difficult to keep aerobic.  However, large piles may be kept aerobic through frequent turning.  Refer to the "Compost Quality Standards" publication listed on the previous page for information on desirable microbiological test results or the Compost Quality Guidelines provided by Organic Ag Advisors and BBC Laboratories, Inc.
  • Stability/Maturity
    In general, beneficial microorganisms are found in mature compost.  See assessing stability/maturity for information on assessing maturity.
  • Nutrients
    Not a significant factor.
  • pH
    Alkaline (pH greater than 7) soils tend to be dominated by bacteria.   Acidic (pH less than 7) soils tend to be dominated by fungi.

Appropriate for seed germination and/or transplants

  • Feedstock Type (Compost Ingredients)
    Compost made from animal manure may not be appropriate for seed germination and transplants since it is frequently higher in salinity than compost made from yard trimmings and woody debris.  Salinity should be assessed through lab analysis.
  • Salinity
    .75-3 dS/m (deciSiemens/meter or millimhos/centimeter) is best for seedlings and young, tender plants.  This should be the salinity of the final growing medium after compost has been applied and blended.
  • Effect of Composting Method
    Aerobically composted material is most appropriate for seed germination and/or transplants.  Compost that is intentionally, or unintentionally, anaerobically composted may contain ammonia and volatile organic acids that are considered toxic to plants.  A smell of ammonia can indicate an immature and/or anaerobically composted material.
  • Stability/Maturity
    Stable and mature compost in combination with fertile soil or potting mix can be safely used for seed germination and/or transplants.  Immature composts usually contain more growth-inhibiting substances that can be toxic to plants.  A germination test is recommended prior to compost use. See assessing compost stability/maturity.
  • Nutrients
    Too much N can sometimes kill seedlings.  In most cases, compost should be blended with soil prior to use for new growth.  A standard blend for nursery use is 15% to 25% compost mixed with a standard wood residual.
  • pH
    pH less than 5 is likely to be immature and contain growth-inhibiting substances that can be toxic to plants.  Best results are likely with compost that is neutral to alkaline (pH greater than or equal to 7).

Will not introduce viable weed seeds or pathogens

  • Feedstock Type (Compost Ingredients)
    The type of feedstock composted will determine the likelihood and the type of noxious weed seeds and pathogens that may be present prior to composting. E. coli and salmonella are most prevalent in manure and biosolid feedstock. Seeds would be most likely in yard trimming feedstock.
  • Salinity
    Not a significant factor.
  • Effect of Composting Method
    Most weed seeds and pathogens are killed by high temperatures during the thermophilic stage of the composting process.  However, some weed seeds are resistant to high temperature.  Pursuant to State regulations (Title 14, California Code of Regulations, Section 17868.3), compost must be exposed to high temperatures for specified periods of time to kill weed seeds and pathogens:

    Windrow method (elongated piles of compostable material that is turned on a periodic basis): 131 degrees F (55 degrees C) for 15 days with a minimum of 5 turnings.
    In-vessel method (compostable material that is enclosed in a container): 131 degrees F (55 degrees C) for 3 days.
    Aerated static pile method (compostable material exposed to an air distribution system that either blows or draws air through the material): 131 degrees F (55 degrees C) for 3 days.

  • Stability/Maturity
    Stable compost is unlikely to contain viable weed seed or plant pathogens.
  • Nutrients
    Not a significant factor.
  • pH
    Not a significant factor.

Will not introduce contaminants

  • Feedstock Type (Compost Ingredients)
    Contaminants in the compost product are dependent upon the type and cleanliness of the feedstock used and the level of grinding and screening. Visual inspection may identify some contaminants, such as plastic bags.

    Trace Elements: Biosolids may be significantly higher in trace elements, including heavy metals, than yard trimmings. However, heavy metals in compost produced by a permitted facility cannot exceed U.S. EPA Part 503 maximum levels.
    Glass, Plastic, and Metal Objects: Yard trimmings vary in the degree of inert contamination.  Plastic sheeting from trash bags is common. However, most of these contaminants can be removed by the processor through adequate screening.

  • Salinity
    Not a significant factor.
  • Effect of Composting Method
    Not a significant factor.
  • Stability/Maturity
    Not a significant factor.
  • Nutrients
    Not a significant factor.
  • pH
    Not a significant factor.

Enhances water holding capacity, soil structure, organic matter, drainage, and nutrient holding capacity of soil

  • Feedstock Type (Compost Ingredients)
    Most compost is high in organic matter. Higher organic matter content in the compost will increase water-holding capacity. It also improves soil structure in both clay and sandy soils.  Because it can break up clay soils, organic matter can help improve drainage. Organic matter also increases cation exchange capacity (CEC). Soils with a high CEC hold onto nutrients and reduce leaching to groundwater. Soil added to the compost may decrease total organic matter.
  • Salinity
    Not a significant factor.
  • Effect of Composting Method
    Compost that is ground and/or screened to a smaller particle size (less than ½ inch) may improve cation exchange capacity (CEC).
  • Stability/Maturity
    Not a significant factor.
  • Nutrients
    Not a significant factor.
  • pH
    An acidic compost (pH less than 7) can have a higher cation exchange capacity (CEC) than an alkaline compost.  At high rates of application, the CEC from compost may be a significant proportion of the total CEC in the soil, especially on sandy substrates.

Does not significantly increase soil salinity

  • Feedstock Type (Compost Ingredients)
    The composition of the feedstock will determine the salinity of the final compost.  The compost process actually concentrates salts so the finished product is higher in salinity than the starting material.  Compost made from animal manure may not be appropriate in specific situations since it is frequently higher in salinity than compost made primarily from yard trimmings or woody debris.
  • Salinity
    Certain crops may not tolerate high-salinity compost.  For most established crops, electrical conductivity (used to measure salinity) of the growing medium (after compost has been applied and blended) should not exceed 5 dS/m.
  • Effect of Composting Method
    Not a significant factor.
  • Stability/Maturity
    Not a significant factor.
  • Nutrients
    Not a significant factor.
  • pH
    Not a significant factor.

Compost Performance Requirements

 

Last updated: August 29, 2008


Organic Materials Management http://www.ciwmb.ca.gov/Organics/
Pat Paswater: PPaswater@ciwmb.ca.gov (916) 341-6593